4

Term Paper 4

In America, there are many press freedoms, which allow everyday citizens to judge and decide on what they want from their government. However, other places around the world have more restrictions than freedoms, with some more severe than others. Some examples of this are in China and Russia.



China



More pressures have been put onto citizens of Hong Kong, which was previously under a democratic system as a British Colony. Over the course of the last few years, more and more restrictions have been put on journalists. Several journalists even go missing or are wrongfully convicted while investigating misconduct.

“The space for free speech has become so limited,”

Zhang Wenmin, an investigative journalist based in Beijing, told The New York Times. “It’s now dangerous to say you are an independent journalist.” Zhang Wenmin is just one of many journalists facing danger while trying to hold their government accountable.

Even citizen journalists, reporting the treatment of citizens and the handling of Coronavirus in Wuhan after the outbreak have their posts scrubbed from search engines and are silenced.



“We’re almost extinct,”




“We’re almost extinct,” said Liu Hu, 43, a reporter from the southwestern province of Sichuan who was detained for nearly a year after investigating corrupt politicians. “No one is left to reveal the truth.” quoted from The New York Times.

The Chinese press is calling for more defense of China’s socialist system. Instead of questioning and scrutinizing their leaders and their actions, leaders of the press act to glorify and praise them while covering up their atrocities. Journalists across the country are urged to create clickbait instead of investigative pieces, which would act to saturate search results and turn attention away from larger issues.

“Issues that used to be covered a lot suddenly became restricted,” said Xue Lei. Xue Lei used to be a reporter for the Beijing Youth Daily, before he quit to work in public relations at a technology firm. “Sometimes you wouldn’t even know where a censorship order was coming from.”

Many refer to this era as an era of censorship for China. “The government has made its citizens ignorant,” Mr. Liu said. “The public’s eyes are blind, their ears are deaf and their mouths have no words.” Without anyone reporting on the truth of these issues, how much longer will it be before citizens are left to live under a monolithic government.



Russia



Another area with heavy censorship is Russia. Alexei Navalny, a Russian lawyer, and corruption activist was recently imprisoned after being poisoned with a Novichok nerve agent, which was developed as a weapon by the Soviet Union and Russia between 1971 and 1993.

"This is the continuation of the old and horrific tradition of torturing political prisoners in the USSR and now Russia," Mr.Kara-Murza believes. "These people know no bounds." quoted from BBC.

Navalny has more than six million YouTube subscribers and more than two million Twitter followers. He would use his platform to share messages about corruption in Russia’s government that he would learn about through his investigations and to organize political protests.

In 2017, Navalny released a documentary, Don’t Call Him “Dimon” that provided evidence of the corrupt acts of former President and Prime Minister, Dmitry Medvedev. In only one week, the video had 7 million views, as of 2021, it has over 44 million views. The documentary lead to mass protests across the country.

It was apparent that Alexei was influential as a reporter and that people trusted his research and transparency. Even if they didn’t trust him, the evidence he provided was so undeniable that the facts would speak for themselves. Of course, this would only lead to trouble and scrutiny for those in power.

After Navalny was poisoned, hospitalized, and detained in Russia. A Russian court sentenced him to 3 1/2 years in a penal colony for violating probation terms. Although, the European Court of Human Rights ruled that Navalny's conviction for fraud and money laundering "was based on an unforeseeable application of criminal law and that the proceedings were arbitrary and unfair” the court upheld their decision.

2 days after he was detained by Russian authorities, an investigation by Navalny and the FBK was uploaded to YouTube.



This documentary, “Putin’s Palace: History of World's Largest Bribe” , accused Putin of committing fraud and using the obtained funds to build a massive estate. This documentary lead to more protests with many calling for the release of Alexei Navalny. Although Putin denied ownership of the palace and the oligarch Arkady Rotenberg claimed ownership, many still are in protest.

The documentary is the most popular video on Russian YouTube according to The Moscow Times. A poll also found that almost 1 in 4 Russians have viewed the documentary. I would also recommend watching the video.

After viewing it, I have to say that it’s a masterpiece of storytelling and it was amazing to see the efforts that Alexei and his team of journalists had to go through to obtain the information they shared with the public.

Alexei Navalny’s story of fighting corruption in Russia is one that almost sounds more like a movie than real life. Which I believe highlights the freedoms we have in America that it seems unreal and dystopian to hear about the difficulties that journalists in other countries have to go through just to communicate the truth to the public.

You Might Also Like

0 comments